Ben White’s abrupt departure from England’s World Cup camp in Qatar has been shrouded in speculation and criticism. Many viewed it as a display of immaturity or a refusal to commit to the national team. However, Arsenal manager Mikel Arteta has now provided a different perspective—one that frames White’s decision as an act of self-awareness rather than defiance.
According to Arteta, White left because he felt he couldn’t contribute in the way that was expected of him. Rather than forcing himself into a situation where he wasn’t mentally prepared, he chose to step away.
This revelation paints a vastly different picture from the earlier assumption that White had merely thrown a tantrum. Arteta emphasized that White’s move was, in fact, courageous, arguing that few players would have the honesty to admit they weren’t in the right headspace to represent their country.
Despite this clarification, White remains absent from the England squad. But with Thomas Tuchel now confirming that the defender is once again eligible for selection after recovering from knee surgery, the debate over his potential return has reignited.
The announcement that White could be in contention for England duty again has divided opinions. Legendary defender Stuart Pearce, for one, has voiced his disapproval, asserting that if a player walks away once, they cannot be trusted again. Others have echoed similar sentiments, questioning whether White deserves a second chance after seemingly turning his back on the team during a crucial tournament.
However, Arteta’s words challenge this narrative. If White’s departure was truly about avoiding letting the team down rather than abandoning them, does he deserve to be permanently sidelined? Football history is filled with players who stepped away from international duty due to personal struggles, only to return stronger and more committed. If White is now in a better frame of mind and performing at a high level for Arsenal, why should England ignore such a talent?
Tuchel’s willingness to reintroduce White suggests that the England setup is open to moving forward. The real question is whether the fans and critics will be as forgiving. Football thrives on redemption stories, but for some, White’s absence in Qatar remains an unforgivable moment of weakness.
